Codicil vs New Will: Which Is Better for Changing Your Will?

📅 Updated October 2026⏱ 7 min read
Written by Sarah Mitchell
Estate Planning Editor · Updated October 2026
Affiliate disclosure: We may earn a commission if you use some links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Editorial policy → This is general information, not legal advice.

🏆 The Short Answer

A codicil is a signed amendment to an existing will. Use one for a single small change, such as swapping an executor. For bigger changes, or multiple changes over time, a new will is usually cleaner and less likely to cause disputes. Either document generally must be signed with the same formalities as a will.

What is a codicil?

Cornell's Legal Information Institute describes a codicil as a supplement that amends or revokes a will in whole or in part. It does not replace the underlying will, so the two documents are read together after you die.

Codicil vs new will: how do they compare?

CodicilNew will
Best forOne or two small changesMajor or multiple changes
SigningSame formalities as a will in most statesStandard will formalities
Risk of confusionHigher if old will and codicils conflictLower, one document
Revokes old will?No, it amends itUsually, with a revocation clause
Cost and effortShort and quickLonger, usually still affordable online

General comparison; rules vary by state.

When is a codicil a good choice?

When should I write a new will instead?

How do I sign a codicil correctly?

In most states a codicil must be in writing, signed by you, and witnessed like a will. Many states require two adult witnesses who are not beneficiaries. Handwriting changes on the original will, crossing out names, or attaching a sticky note can invalidate the change or the will, so avoid them. Some states accept a self-proving affidavit with notary; check your state's rules. Keep the codicil with the original will.

What is the easiest way to make a new will?

Online services let you create and update a will without starting from scratch. See our best online will maker guide. Trust & Will is the partner we link to for guided will and trust packages; check its current pricing and update policy on its site. You can also compare free options. If your estate is complex or contested, see an attorney.

Also review beneficiary designations on retirement accounts and insurance when you change a will, because they override it (guide).

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a codicil to a will?

A codicil is a signed legal amendment that changes part of an existing will without replacing it.

Is a codicil legally binding?

Yes, if it meets your state's requirements, which generally mirror those for a will, including signing and witnesses.

Can I change my will without a lawyer?

Often yes, with a properly signed codicil or a new will. For complex situations, a lawyer lowers the risk of error.

How many codicils are too many?

There is no legal limit, but several codicils make the documents hard to read together. Many people rewrite the will after one or two.

Does a new will cancel my old will?

A new will usually includes a clause revoking prior wills. Without that clause, conflicting parts of older wills may still matter.

Does a codicil need witnesses?

Generally yes. Follow your state's will-signing requirements for witnesses.

Can I write a codicil by hand?

Some states accept handwritten changes in limited cases. See our holographic wills guide; a typed, witnessed codicil is safer.

Sources: Cornell LII, Codicil. State rules vary; confirm with your state's probate code or an attorney.

Not Sure Which Document Fits Your Situation?

Our 60-second quiz points you to the right service.

Take the Free Quiz →